If you have underpaid tax, whether through an honest mistake or something you knew about at the time, you can put it right by making a voluntary disclosure to HMRC. Coming forward before HMRC contacts you almost always produces a lower penalty, and in most cases it keeps the matter civil. This guide explains how the process works, how far back you have to go, what penalties to expect and when you need a different route altogether.
What is a voluntary disclosure?
A voluntary disclosure is where you tell HMRC about tax you owe that it does not yet know about. HMRC calls this an unprompted disclosure. If you only come forward once HMRC has opened a compliance check, or has given you reason to believe it is about to, the disclosure is treated as prompted and the minimum penalties are higher.
Most disclosures are made online through HMRC’s Digital Disclosure Service (DDS). Individuals and companies can use it for Income Tax, Capital Gains Tax, Corporation Tax, National Insurance contributions, Inheritance Tax and the Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings. It cannot be used for VAT errors, which have their own process (see below).
How far back does a voluntary disclosure go?
The number of years you must disclose depends on why the tax was underpaid, not on how much is owed:
- You took reasonable care but still got it wrong: up to 4 years.
- You were careless: up to 6 years.
- The behaviour was deliberate: up to 20 years.
- You never told HMRC you were liable to tax (failure to notify): up to 20 years.
- Offshore income, gains or assets: up to 12 years, and longer where the behaviour was deliberate.
Deciding which category applies is the single most important judgement in a disclosure. It sets the number of years, the penalty range and whether the Digital Disclosure Service is the right route at all. HMRC can and does reject disclosures where the behaviour has been understated.
How to make a voluntary disclosure to HMRC
- Notify HMRC. You tell HMRC that you intend to make a disclosure. You do not need the figures at this stage. Each person or company needs its own notification.
- Receive your reference. HMRC acknowledges the notification and issues a disclosure reference number and a payment reference.
- Prepare the disclosure. You have 90 days from HMRC’s acknowledgement to work out the undeclared income or gains for every year in scope, and to calculate the tax, interest and penalty.
- Make your offer and pay. The disclosure includes a formal offer to pay the full amount. Payment is due by the same 90-day deadline.
- HMRC reviews it. HMRC may accept the disclosure as submitted or ask for more information. Once accepted, the offer and HMRC’s acceptance letter form a binding contract.
If you cannot pay in full, speak to HMRC before you submit the disclosure. Time to pay has to be agreed in advance, not afterwards.
What penalties will you pay?
Penalties are a percentage of the tax owed. The range depends on the behaviour and on whether the disclosure was unprompted or prompted. For an inaccurate return involving UK income or gains, the ranges are:
| Behaviour | Unprompted disclosure | Prompted disclosure |
|---|---|---|
| Reasonable care | No penalty | No penalty |
| Careless | 0% to 30% | 15% to 30% |
| Deliberate | 20% to 70% | 35% to 70% |
| Deliberate and concealed | 30% to 100% | 50% to 100% |
Where you land within the range depends on the quality of the disclosure: how fully you tell HMRC what happened, how much you help it quantify the tax, and how readily you give access to records. Penalties for offshore matters are higher and can reach 200% of the tax. Where tax has gone undisclosed for a long time, normally more than three years, HMRC restricts the reduction it will give.
Interest is charged on top, running from the date the tax was originally due until it is paid.
When the Digital Disclosure Service is the wrong route
If tax was lost because of deliberate behaviour, the Digital Disclosure Service gives you no protection from criminal investigation. The route for that is the Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF), operated under HMRC’s Code of Practice 9. In return for a complete and accurate disclosure of the deliberate conduct, HMRC agrees not to pursue a criminal investigation into it. Choosing the wrong route is very difficult to undo, so take advice before you notify. We explain how these cases run on our HMRC investigations and forensic accounting page.
HMRC also runs facilities for particular situations, each of which sits within the disclosure service:
- Let Property Campaign for landlords with undeclared rental income.
- Worldwide Disclosure Facility for offshore income, gains and assets.
- Cryptoasset disclosure for undeclared gains or income from crypto.
Voluntary disclosure for Corporation Tax
A company can amend its Company Tax Return within 12 months of the filing deadline, so a recent error is usually corrected that way. For earlier periods, the company makes a disclosure through the Digital Disclosure Service in its own name. Directors who have also underdeclared personal income, for example dividends or benefits, need a separate notification as individuals. Our limited company disclosure case study shows how this works in practice.
What about VAT errors?
VAT is outside the Digital Disclosure Service. Smaller net errors can be corrected on your next VAT return. Larger errors, and any deliberate error, must be reported to HMRC separately using form VAT652.
Had a letter from HMRC?
HMRC regularly writes to taxpayers it believes may have undeclared income, often using data from banks, letting agents, online platforms and overseas tax authorities. A letter of this kind does not close the door on a disclosure, but it may mean HMRC treats it as prompted. Do not ignore it and do not reply in a hurry. If a formal check has already started, read our guide on what to do when your business has an HMRC enquiry.
Frequently asked questions
Will I be prosecuted if I make a voluntary disclosure?
The large majority of disclosures are settled on a civil basis with tax, interest and a penalty. Where deliberate behaviour is involved, only the Contractual Disclosure Facility gives an assurance against criminal investigation.
Will my name be published?
HMRC can publish details of deliberate defaulters. You are generally protected from publication where you come forward unprompted, disclose fully, pay on time and co-operate throughout.
Do I need the exact figures before I notify?
No. Notification only tells HMRC a disclosure is coming. The figures follow within the 90 days.
What if I find something else after I have submitted?
Tell HMRC straight away. An incomplete disclosure can lead to much higher penalties and, in serious cases, a criminal investigation.
Speak to us before you notify
MJ Kane & Co specialises in HMRC enquiry and disclosure work. The decisions made before the notification goes in, which route, which years and which behaviour, determine most of the outcome. Book a confidential consultation or contact us to talk it through.